Team Trophies
- 2007 Nye Frontier Challenge Champions
- 2012 Three Rivers Classic Champions
- 2013-14 AHA Tournament Champions
- 2014-15 AHA Regular Season Champions
- 2015 Three Rivers Classic Champions
- 2015-16 AHA Regular Season Champions
- 2016 Three Rivers Classic Champions
- 2021 AHA West Division Regular Season
Player Trophies
- 2007-08 CHA Player of the Year: Ryan Cruthers
-
2007-08 CHA Student-Athlete of the Year: Joel Gaspar
- 2010-11 AHA Defenseman of the Year: Denny Urban
- 2010-11 AHA Individual Sportsmanship Award: Furman South
- 011-12 AHA Defensive Forward of the Year: Nick Chiavetta
- 2013-14 AHA Tournament MVP: Cody Wydo
- 2014-15 AHA Player of the Year: Zac Lynch
- 2014-15 Hobey Baker Finalist: Cody Wydo
- 2015-16 Hobey Baker Finalist Zac Lynch
- 2015-16 AHA Regular Season Scoring Title: Zac Lynch
- 2016-17 AHA Regular Season Scoring Title: Brady Ferguson
- 2020-21 AHA West Player of the Year: Nick Prkusic
- 2020-21 AHA West Defenseman of the Year: Nick Jenny
- 2020-21 AHA Rookie of the Year: Randy Hernandez
- 2020-21 AHA Individual Sportsmanship Award: Nick Jenny
Coach Awards
- 2014-15 Atlantic Hockey Association Coach of the Year: Derek Schooley
- 2020-21 Atlantic Hockey Association Coach of the Year: Derek Schooley
All-Conference Team Awards
All-CHA First Team
- 2007-08: Ryan Cruthers
- 2008-09: Denny Urban
- 2008-09: Chris Margott
- 2008-09: Nathan Longpre
- 2009-10: Denny Urban
- 2009-10: Nathan Longpre
All-CHA Second Team
- 2006-07: Aaron Clarke
- 2007-08: Chris Margott
- 2009-10: Dave Cowen
- 2009-10: Chris Kushneriuk
CHA All-Rookie Team
- 2004-05: Chris Kaufman
- 2004-05: Jace Buzek
- 2005-06: Chris Margott
- 2007-08: Denny Urban
- 2007-08: Nathan Longpre
- 2008-09: Brooks Ostergard
- 2008-09: James Lyle
- 2009-10: Stefan Salituro
First Team All-AHA
- 2010-11: Denny Urban
- 2010-11: Nathan Longpre
- 2013-14: Cody Wydo
- 2014-15: Cody Wydo
- 2015-16: Greg Gibson
- 2015-16: Zac Lynch
- 2016-17: Brady Ferguson
- 2017-18: Brady Ferguson
- 2020-21: Nick Jenny
- 2020-21: Nick Prkusic
Second Team All-AHA
- 2012-13: Adam Brace
- 2015-16: Tyson Wilson
- 2018-19: Alex Tonge
- 2019-20: Justin Kapelmaster
- 2020-21: Noah West
- 2020-21: Brendon Michaelian
- 2020-21: Randy Hernandez
Third Team All-AHA
- 2010-11: Brooks Ostergard
- 2011-12: Cody Chrichton
- 2013-14: Terry Shafer
- 2014-15: Dalton Izyk
- 2014-15: Chase Golightly
- 2014-15: Zac Lynch
- 2015-16: Terry Shafer
- 2015-16: Chase Golightly
- 2015-16: Brendon Denham
- 2016-17: Eric Israel
- 2016-17: Daniel Leavens
- 2017-18: Alex Tonge
- 2018-19: Francis Marotte
AHA All-Rookie Team
- 2011-12: Tyson Wilson
- 2014-15: Brady Ferguson
- 2016-17: Francis Marotte
- 2020-21: Noah West
- 2020-21: Brian Kramer
- 2020-21: Randy Hernandez
